Wow, then it must be just me, as I think MSX's Adventure Island is a real pain in the ass, comparing it to the enjoyment of the SMS or Gamegear version of Wonderboy
. And please note that I love both Wonderboy and Adventure Island games! (that last one has a really brilliant NES version!). The MSX one is, by far, the worst conversion of all systems... and that's not for the gfx, that are btw really cool, but for the scrolling, that takes playability to a lower level.
I haven't played those versions, so I can't tell you if the MSX one is the worse or not... I only say I really enjoyed it although it has 8x8 scrolling. Anyway it was just an example.
In the other hand, there are nice MSX games with 8x8 scroll that really rock, due to its speedy scroll: games such as Road Fighter, Magical Tree (that has a really nice vertical scrolling routine in which several lines are scrolled at a high speed when needed, instead of doing it line by line)... Magical Kid Wiz is another 8x8 scroller that looks pretty nice, as the scroll is kinda speedy too...
You're right.
so, ok, a G'n'G with an 8x8 scroll would surely rock too, but I wouldn't lose the oportunity to give a try to a smooth-scrolling project, just to enhance gamer's experience with the platforms and the whole game too... another option would be to scroll 8x8 several columns in a speedy way when a certain xpos is reached...
You know perfectly the CPU cost of the 1x1 scroll and I think G'n'G has A LOT of things to move and to control. It will be really hard to get something similar to the original (talking about playability).
Btw, it would be really nice if the difficulty level is a bit adjusted, because the arcade is really hard.
but my best option is 1x1 scroll, that's for sure
I know it for sure!
Btw, Mr. Imanok, there was a nice project we were talking about long ago, where 8x8 horizontal scroll would fit really well... are you still considering that project or not?
Of course I'm considering it